Emotional Support Animals and Liability in Indiana Dog Bite Incidents

Emotional support animals play an important role in the lives of many individuals, offering comfort and companionship to those who need it. In Indiana, as in many other states, emotional support animals (ESAs) are protected under certain laws, ensuring that people with emotional or mental health conditions can benefit from their companionship. However, when these animals are involved in incidents such as dog bites, questions about liability can arise. Who is responsible when an emotional support animal causes harm to another person? Understanding the laws surrounding ESAs and dog bite liability in Indiana is crucial for both animal owners and potential victims.

Understanding Emotional Support Animals in Indiana

Emotional support animals are different from service animals. While service animals are trained to perform specific tasks for individuals with disabilities, emotional support animals provide comfort and emotional stability to those suffering from mental or emotional health conditions. This distinction is important when it comes to legal protections and liability. In Indiana, emotional support animals are not granted the same privileges as service animals, meaning they may not have the same rights to enter public spaces or other areas where pets are typically not allowed. However, they do enjoy certain protections under federal laws such as the Fair Housing Act, which allows individuals to keep their emotional support animals in housing that might otherwise prohibit pets.

Despite these protections, emotional support animals are still animals, and like all animals, they can pose risks, including the potential to bite or harm others. Understanding the liability surrounding emotional support animals in the case of a dog bite is essential for both ESA owners and those who may come into contact with these animals.

Liability in Dog Bite Cases Involving Emotional Support Animals

In Indiana, dog bite liability is governed by a combination of state laws and legal precedents. The state operates under what is known as a “strict liability” rule in certain situations, meaning that dog owners can be held liable for injuries their dog causes, even if the dog has never shown aggression before. This is especially true for cases where a person is bitten by a dog while lawfully on the owner’s property, such as a postal worker or utility worker.

Attorney Christopher Wyant is here to help you. 

With over 17 years of experience, Attorney Wyant has spent his entire legal career representing individuals who have been injured or killed as a result of the carelessness of others. With trial experience in over 20 jury trials, he has handled cases involving wrongful death and personal injury arising out of automobile crashes, premises liability, slips and falls, dog attacks, and civil rights violations.

 

When it comes to emotional support animals, the rules of liability remain largely the same as with any other dog. If an ESA bites or attacks someone, the owner can be held liable for any damages or injuries resulting from the incident. However, there are nuances in how liability is determined, especially if the animal’s role as an emotional support companion is considered.

In cases involving emotional support animals, the owner’s responsibility to ensure that their animal does not pose a danger to others is still paramount. Just because an animal serves an emotional purpose does not exempt the owner from legal responsibility if the animal bites someone. Courts will typically evaluate the circumstances of the bite, including whether the animal had a history of aggression, whether the owner took proper precautions to prevent the bite, and the actions of the victim at the time of the incident.

The Role of Negligence in Dog Bite Cases

Negligence is often a key factor in dog bite cases involving emotional support animals. In Indiana, an owner may be found negligent if they failed to exercise reasonable care in controlling their dog or in preventing the dog from biting someone. For instance, if an emotional support animal has shown signs of aggression in the past and the owner failed to take steps to restrain the animal or warn others, this could be considered negligence.

Additionally, owners of emotional support animals are expected to follow local laws and ordinances regarding pet ownership. This includes keeping the animal on a leash when in public or ensuring that the animal is properly secured on private property. Failure to adhere to these regulations can further bolster a claim of negligence in the event of a dog bite.

It’s also important to note that in Indiana, comparative fault rules may come into play. This means that if the victim of the dog bite was partially responsible for the incident—for example, if they provoked the dog—the amount of compensation they can recover may be reduced based on their level of fault. However, even if the victim is found to be partially at fault, the owner of the emotional support animal can still be held liable for their portion of the blame.

My husband and I were involved in an auto accident. The driver that hit us was without a doubt at fault. In less than 2 days we were getting calls from the driver’s insurance company wanting us to accept 15% fault. The calls kept coming to try and push us into a settlement. We decided to get legal help and found Chris Wyant. Once Chris took over we felt a big load lifted. He is very knowledgeable, well prepared and makes everything so much easier to understand the process. Chris has a very diligent work ethic that gets results. We are so very grateful to have found Chris. We highly recommend Chris Wyant.”

- Kathaleen Boyce

Chris was awesome from the very first meeting. Very professional and knowledgeable. He knew what needed to be done and what he needed from us. He was exceptionally easy to work with and very patient with all of the questions we had. All we had to do was either call or email him with a question and he responded as quickly as he could. I couldn’t be happier with his services. I would definitely recommend his practice to anyone."

- Rita Bridge

God Bless Wyant Law. I can honestly say that Chris went to bat for me in such a huge way during such a trying time. He was very professional and upfront about every step he took. I would 100 percent recommend Wyant Law for your legal needs."

- Briana Shouse

Legal Protections for Emotional Support Animal Owners

While emotional support animal owners can be held liable for dog bites, there are also certain legal protections available to them under Indiana law. One of the most common defenses raised in dog bite cases is that the victim was trespassing or otherwise unlawfully on the owner’s property at the time of the bite. Indiana law generally protects dog owners from liability in cases where the victim was not lawfully on the property, although this defense may not apply in every case.

Another defense often raised is that the victim provoked the animal, leading to the bite. If the owner can prove that the victim’s actions directly caused the animal to react aggressively, this can limit or eliminate the owner’s liability. However, proving provocation can be challenging, as it often relies on witness testimony and other forms of evidence.

For emotional support animal owners, it is also important to understand that their animal’s role as a companion does not necessarily provide additional legal protection in a dog bite case. While emotional support animals are recognized for their important role in providing comfort and companionship, they are still subject to the same liability rules as any other pet. As such, owners must take the necessary precautions to ensure that their emotional support animal does not pose a danger to others.

Related Videos

Preventing Dog Bite Incidents Involving Emotional Support Animals

For emotional support animal owners, the best way to avoid liability in a dog bite case is to take proactive steps to prevent incidents from occurring in the first place. This includes training the animal to be obedient and well-behaved, particularly around strangers. While emotional support animals are not required to undergo the same level of training as service animals, basic obedience training can go a long way in preventing dangerous situations.

Owners should also be mindful of their animal’s temperament and take appropriate action if the animal shows signs of aggression. For example, if an emotional support dog becomes anxious or agitated in crowded or unfamiliar environments, the owner should avoid placing the dog in those situations. Similarly, if the animal has a history of biting or aggression, the owner should take extra precautions, such as using a muzzle or ensuring that the dog is always securely restrained.

In public settings, emotional support animal owners should adhere to all local leash laws and regulations, keeping their dog under control at all times. Even in situations where the dog may not appear to be a threat, it is the owner’s responsibility to prevent the dog from becoming a danger to others.

For victims of dog bite incidents involving emotional support animals, understanding the laws surrounding liability is crucial. If you have been injured by an emotional support animal in Indiana, it is important to seek legal guidance to determine your rights and options for pursuing compensation. A qualified attorney can help you navigate the complexities of Indiana’s dog bite laws and work to secure the compensation you deserve for your injuries.

If you or a loved one has been injured by an emotional support animal or any other dog in Indiana, Wyant Law is here to help. Our team understands the challenges and emotional toll that dog bite incidents can take, and we are committed to advocating for your rights. Whether you are seeking compensation for medical expenses, pain and suffering, or other damages, we can provide the legal guidance you need. Contact Wyant Law today for a consultation to discuss your case and learn how we can assist you in your recovery. We are here to help you navigate the legal process and pursue the justice you deserve.